Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Single-vendor integrated network vs. best of breed: Why single vendor is best

Wide Area Networking Alert Network World logo
NetworkWorld.com | LANs & WANs Research Center | Update Your Profile
Single-vendor integrated network vs. best of breed: Why single vendor is best

Steve Taylor By Steve Taylor and Jim Metzler
If the reaction to the discussion back in October on whether application optimization should be integrated into the router is any indication, our point-counterpoint discussions can generate some heated debate. While there were no comments that reached SNL's "Jane, you ignorant slut," countered with "Dan, you pompous ass," we did get some comments that got both technical and passionate. Today, we're raising yet another perennial question: Is it better to have a homogeneous network for consistency, or does a heterogeneous network where the customer chooses what they believe to be "best of breed" in each respect provide the best overall reliability? Read full story

Steve Taylor is president of Distributed Networking Associates and publisher/editor-in-chief of Webtorials. For more detailed information on most of the topics discussed in this newsletter, connect to Webtorials, the premier site for Web-based educational presentations, white papers, and market research. Taylor can be reached at taylor@webtorials.com

Jim Metzler is the Vice President of Ashton, Metzler & Associates, a consulting organization that focuses on leveraging technology for business success. Jim assists vendors to refine product strategies, service providers to deploy technologies and services, and enterprises evolve their network infrastructure. He can be reached via e-mail.


SPONSORED BY SOLARWINDS
rule

Experiencing Network Hang-ups?
Proactively analyze call quality across WAN links and monitor the underlying systems and protocols that the VoIP environment relies upon with Orion VoIP Monitor. Download your free 30-day trial of VoIP Monitor and get detailed performance reporting in minutes.

rule
RELATED NEWS:

NetworkWorld.com Buyer's Guides, 11/25/07: Network World Buyer's Guides provide you with the most detailed and accurate information on thousands of network and IT products from anti-spam to application acceleration to storage management wares. Make informed buying decisions for your enterprise ...

Packeteer takes on gaming, instant messaging, 11/19/2007 Packeteer has released software plug-ins for its WAN optimization gear so they can identify and control instant messaging, video and online gaming ...

How to secure Cisco routers: Michael Behringer, MPLS security expert has advice on how to secure your Cisco routers - make them unreachable and auto-secure them.

FINAL WEEK TO ENTER TO WIN: Free copies of MPLS VPN Security book; Free Cisco training course worth up to $3,495; Enter to win a free copy of MPLS VPN Security by Michael Behringer and Monique Morrow, published by Cisco Press. Also, you can enter to win a free Cisco training course of your choosing, worth up to $3,495, courtesy of Cisco learning partner Skyline-ATS.

Juniper beats Cisco's gains in carrier Ethernet router market: Juniper and Cisco continue to tussle it out in the global router and switch market. According to Synergy Research Group, Juniper increased its share of the global carrier Ethernet router market by 1.7% in the third quarter, compared to just 0.6% for Cisco.


BIG THREATS IN '08
Top 5 security threats in 2008Top 5 security-menace predictions for next year.

ALL-IN-ONE FIREWALL TEST
idemandJuniper, Check Point, Cisco lead way in test of 13 UTM devices.

SPONSORED BY SOLARWINDS
rule

Experiencing Network Hang-ups?
Proactively analyze call quality across WAN links and monitor the underlying systems and protocols that the VoIP environment relies upon with Orion VoIP Monitor. Download your free 30-day trial of VoIP Monitor and get detailed performance reporting in minutes.

rule

Join Network World's Technology Opinion Panel
Here is your chance to help shape the future of IT. You know what products and enhancements are needed, you have the insight and foresight to be out front and provide direction to Network Word and the network industry. To join the panel, complete a brief registration survey
. The panel is strictly for technology professionals to share their vision.

Featured reader resource

90% of IT Managers are leaving their company at risk for a DNS ATTACK. Get the tools and resources you need to keep your DNS healthy and secure. Run a DNSreport on your domain today - 56 critical tests run in 8 seconds.

Visit www.dnsreport.com to learn more. (apply coupon NWW2007NLA for a 25% membership discount)

 

11/27/07

TODAY'S MOST-READ STORIES:

  1. BSA, software giants target little guys
  2. 2007 Cool Yule Tools Gift Guide
  3. Teleworkers called back to cubicle life
  4. '07 Enterprise all-stars
  5. Testing all-in-one firewalls
  6. Security concerns cloud virtualization
  7. Hackers jack Monster.com
  8. Google building 10G Ethernet switches
  9. Cutting-edge spam research projects
  10. Verizon tests 100Gbps network

MOST-READ TEST:
Testing all-in-one firewalls


Executive Guide "Data Center Decisions"

Download our new Executive Guide "Data Center Decisions" to sharpen your competitive edge. This guide offers tips on dealing with server consolidation, virtualization, management, cooling and power issues.

Click Here for More Information



IT Buyers guide

IT Buyer's Guides
Compare products, get advice, and check out tests and reviews from the experts at Network World. Over 70 categories. Visit now.

 


To continue receiving NetworkWorld's Wide Area Networking Alert newsletter, please add @nwfnews.com to your white list.

COMPLIMENTARY SUBSCRIPTIONS AVAILABLE
As a NW newsletter subscriber you are eligible to receive 50 issues of Network World Magazine, in print or electronic format, free of charge.

Sign up for your subscription today: Apply here. International subscribers,click here.

 

SUBSCRIPTION SERVICES
To subscribe or unsubscribe to any Network World newsletter, change your e-mail address or contact us, click here.

Terms of Service/Privacy

Network World, Inc., 118 Turnpike Road, Southborough, MA 01772
Copyright Network World, Inc., 2007

 

 



1 comment:

Justin Lofton said...

Most IT professional are rushing to figure out which WAN acceleration vendors have what it takes to get the job done. As many organizations use Cisco for their networking infrastructure they are also considering Cisco WAAS for WAN optimization and application acceleration.